Huntington is open 8 am-8 pm 7 days a week. 631-683-5500
43 Green St, Huntington, NY
South Shore Opening in 2026: 9 Third Avenue, Bay Shore, NY
We have a run, don't walk situation here. Mighty Fine is making some of Long Island's best pies and more.
Erica Marcus, Newsday April 2026
That rib eye sandwich is so tender and flavorful that I took my time enjoying each bite.
James K. of Oyster Bay
Hey, save the trip to Riverhead for pies! These are really delicious. Give your sweet tooth a day of delight.
Long Island Restaurant Group
Your quiche is the best -- truly the best. Great smooth custard, wondeful crust and fillings.
Renowned LI Interior Designer
Cooking is like love. It should be entered into with abandon or not at all.
Harriet Van Horne
I am always open to drinking while eating pie!
Irene Li - founder of Mei Mei Dumplings