Huntington is open 8 am-8 pm 7 days a week. summer hours Fri & Sat til 10
43 Green St, Huntington, NY
South Shore Opening in 2026: 9 Third Avenue, Bay Shore, NY
We have a run, don't walk situation here. Mighty Fine is making some of Long Island's best pies and more.
Erica Marcus, Newsday April 2026
That rib eye sandwich is so tender and flavorful that I took my time enjoying each bite.
James K. of Oyster Bay
The Upper Crust backyard bar is the only spot around that has a lovely garden & great cocktails. I'll be there every weekend with friends & family.
Annemarie S.. of Cold Spring Harbor
Hey, save the trip to Riverhead for pies! These are really delicious. Give your sweet tooth a day of delight.
Long Island Restaurant Group
Your quiche is the best -- truly the best. Great smooth custard, wondeful crust and fillings.
Renowned LI Interior Designer
I am always open to drinking while eating pie!
Irene Li - founder of Mei Mei Dumplings